Theodore Roosevelt – Larger Than Life

Teddy - Large Than Life
Theodore Roosevelt – Larger Than Life
Author – Matt Donnelly
Publisher – Linnet Books North Haven, Connecticut

Over all a disappointing read, I’m not sure if it’s because I had high expectations of the author or Teddy Roosevelt. Many folks I know hold him in high esteem and there is much about him to admire, but according to the tale spun by this author there seem to be some glaring inconsistencies.

For instance, the author’s understanding that Roosevelt thought the government should bear the burden of the poor while at the same time holding his father’s views that it was part of the duty of individuals with wealth to serve those who were less fortunate. It seems to me that these are two conflicting views. One subscribes to a more biblical understanding that charity is a free gift based on a compassionate heart. The other says that it is forced by the sword of the state. This is either an inconsistent belief or an inconsistent assumption of someone’s belief.

This type of modernizing the past along with some liberal interpretation of facts surrounding the War Between The States, and the praise of feminism leads me to believe it is the author not the subject that is lacking.

It has a good time line and is a good overview of the larger facts that do not give room for outside interpretation, but I think I will still have to pick up a copy of “Carry a Big Stick: The Uncommon Heroism of Theodore Roosevelt” by George Grant and see what I can learn from someone with a more biblical worldview.

2 Comments

  • […] In my post Theodore Roosevelt – Larger Than Life I completely underestimated the complexity of one of the greatest occupants of the American white house. Truly, I don’t think there could be a more complex person to write about. The oddest part of it all is that Teddy Roosevelt did not consider himself anything beyond average. In an assessment of his own ability he wrote: In most things, I am just average; in some of them a little under, rather than over. I am only an ordinary walker. I can’t run. I am not a good swimmer, although I am a strong one. I probably ride better than anything else I do, but I’m certainly not a remarkably good rider. I am not a good shot. I never could be a good boxer, although I do keep at it, whenever I can. My eyesight prevents me from ever being a good tennis player, even if otherwise I could qualify. I am not a brilliant writer. I have written a great deal, but I always have to work and slave over everything I write. The things I have done are all, with the possible exception of the Panama Canal, just such things as any ordinary man could have done. There is nothing brilliant or outstanding in my record at all. page 125 Here is an average man with his average Rough Riders! […]

  • […] my post Theodore Roosevelt – Larger Than Life I completely underestimated the complexity of one of the greatest occupants of the American white […]

Leave a Comment